25th February 2016
It looks like the wee ugly one, aka Jose Mourinho might be the next in line to the throne at the theatre of dreams. Since Alex Ferguson’s departure it has often been a palace of torture for all the fans and no doubt also the board.
However the board have only themselves to blame because they failed to address the most obvious need of the organisation – to manage the succession of the greatest football manager of all time.
The greatest football manager of all time had flirted with retirement once before and surely by all standards having a 70 year old at the helm of any company is surely a signal to look to the future but the decision to retire was not planned from the boardroom .
Fergie’s retirement was sparked by the death of his sister in law and within a season he was away. In the season of his departure it appears that all the managers of top flight European clubs were tied up and David Moyes was the obvious candidate. In his book “Leading” this plan appears quite plausible.
Perhaps another course of reasoning could be followed:
The Glazers were largely laissez faire in their leadership and who could blame them as the partnership of Alex Ferguson and David Gill (chief executive) had seen trophies and balance sheet successs appear routine. David Gill decided that he would go at the same time as Fergie; great timing once more for the board.
Alex Ferguson would care deeply about the future of the club and the Glazers would follow his lead on the plan to replace him.
Perhaps he made a classic mistake similar to that of many owner managers which was to recruit in his own image. David Moyes, a fellow Glaswegian had shown very steady effective management of smaller clubs , he had shown to have fierce determination, discipline and the Scottish work ethic. Not only did they appoint him, they gave him similar conditions to that which Fergie was afforded when he came to Man U in 1986 – time. So David Moyes was appointed and given given a 6 year deal. In simple terms the job proved too much for him and the precious commodity of time ran out under the pressure from the media and the fans.
When Alex Ferguson joined Manchester United it was a big small business, the owner Martin Edwards had inherited the family business and it operated efficiently within the parameters of match day revenue, standard sponsorship and the little contribution from TV. By the time Fergie was in his swan song period the business had grown by a factor of 4/5 times the size.
Although Man U is now a very big sporting brand, yet by financials and number of employees, the club is still a medium sized business. (Turnover c £400m employees c 800). Its biggest shareholding and influence on the board is in the hands of the Glazer family. The environment in which it operates is very different from the world of English football of the 80’s and 90′ s.Most notably the market for players and the market for managers has grown and spread with the same dynamic as the global reach of TV viewing and therein lies the issue with the final year or two of Ferguson at Manchester United – recruitment of players and succession plans for their leader.
Yet despite the very particular nature of a football club such as Man U and the unique leader that Ferguson was there are still a number of wise strategies which owner managers could take from the book. The sections on “listening” and “talking” are worthy of many a re-read. Here, in summary, are my insights from throughout the book:
Take the long term view. “If you have owners or shareholders who only think about short term results, it brings a never ending cycle of misery for everyone.”
Build the organisation – constantly. “If you want to build a winning organisation you have to be prepared to carry on building everyday. You never stop building – if you do, you stagnate.”
Don’t set goals in specific terms but aim for the absolute best. ” My job was to set very high standards. It was to help everyone to believe they could do things they didn’t think they were capable of.”
Money isn’t the motivator. “The more powerful incentives are to appeal to their competitive instinct,the pride they have in their profession and the prospect of a winner’s medal.”
Don’t waste money – ever. “6 years before I retired the kit man told me that we were going through hundreds of shirts. I told the players they could keep swapping their shirts but that they would have to pay for them out of their own pocket.”
Pursue perfection. “At United we are expected to win every game. I believe that and the route to that success was built on two things – continual devotion to improving technical skills and the constant enhancement of tactics”.
Be in your employees shoes. “At half time I would make some observations about what I had seen and try to tighten everything up. I made a habit of never going round issuing reminders to individual players. It just plants seeds of doubt in their minds and they are left wondering if the manager trusts them.”
Make it one team. “If the people within your organisation feel they are part of a community that has there interests at heart, they will develop great loyalty. I disagreed with the chairman when we were building Carrington – I wanted everyone to mingle and eat lunch together, not have a dining room for the 1st team only. Everyone felt part of the set up.”
We won’t see the likes of him again and it is hard to imagine that any manager will run a football club they way Fergie ran Man U, for that is what he did. It was his club, he ruled it, he lead it and shaped in his own image. Little wonder the Glazers couldn’t see beyond him.
“This isn’t an initiative, this isn’t a programme. Eric has helped us create our own unique way of raising the bar on service and keeping us ahead of the competition.”
Greig Brown, CEO, Europa Bilfinger Services.
“This was the first time a newly formed senior leadership team had taken time out to consider strategy, leadership and developing the company. Everyone benefitted from the straight forward and focused approach taken by Eric. OES is a privately owned SME and Eric was chosen specifically for his background in working with this business sector. There was no ‘business school’ terminology nor did Eric try to make us into something we are not. He was there to facilitate, assist, guide, prompt and instruct when required. The open approach worked extremely well across a diverse team with varying levels of leadership experience. The outputs of a strategic plan, leadership actions and longer term goals are now being actively pursued.”
Euan Lockhart CEO of OES Oilfield Services
Unlike other consultants, you can actually see Eric’s effect! It’s real and it improves not only the service but the business performance as well. He also has the ability to engage with people at all levels in the company and that was a major impact in helping to make the connection between their behaviour and outstanding service.
Chris Nugent, Managing Director, Palmaris
The work we did on sharing our leadership agendas was a massive step forward. We would never have done this ourselves. You enabled us to look at ourselves and each other. We were then much more able to communicate openly and comfortably about the way ahead for all of us. You didn’t theorise about it but brought it back to individual experiences and applications.
Everyone values the personal and private nature of the one to ones – they have helped enormously.
Lindsay Campbell, Managing Director, Grant Management
I have known and worked with Eric for many years. He intimately understands the challenges and realities of achieving growth and change in small to medium sized businesses.
We particularly value his perspectives on the need for organisational change if you are to achieve successful strategy implementation – and, of course, on how to make that change happen. The nub of the issues is, of course, leadership and the strategies and tactics that management teams need to adopt in order to achieve successful change. Eric excels in working with boards and senior management teams to plan and implement strategic change – making a positive impact both on how the team operates and the leadership behaviour of individual team members.
Bill Loch, Strategic Development Director, Asco Ltd
Created over many years and continually updated these programmes are unique. Unique because they help you to create your distinctive way of operating, delivering value for your customers and leading your people.
The most challenging aspect of any business is making strategic changes. That’s what Eric Flannigan supports and excels at, he has helped scores of company leaders make change happen.